Continental European before 1800 31 Is this a painting by Carlo Dolci?

COL_GAG_387
Topic: Artist

In my view the painting is definitely Florentine mid-seventeenth century. The most likely candidate here is Carlo Dolci on the basis of several paintings from this period, including the attached. During this time, Dolci also worked on various sets of the Four Evangelists, and most of them were in an octagonal format like the present example - https://bit.ly/3tY4OIg. Having said this, we would need a better photo for further comments. There were many good artists working in Dolci's circle, including Mario Balassi and Ottavio Vannini who were both competent enough to paint the City of London's painting.

Nicholas De Gaetano, Entry reviewed by Art UK

1 attachment

31 comments

Jacinto Regalado,

This does not look sufficiently finished to be autograph Dolci.

Jacinto Regalado,

From what I can find online, the work of both Balassi and Vannini tended to be more highly finished than this picture appears to be. Perhaps the photo is a bit out of focus. A high-resolution image is definitely needed.

Martin Hopkinson,

None of these three artists are convincing candidates as the painter of this work

Nicholas De Gaetano,

I'm pleased that a debate is forming here, and I encourage you and others to comment further and suggest alternative attributions.

May I add that the painting we're discussing probably depicts St Mark the evangelist and not St Jerome. Even though the inclusion of the skull is rare in depictions of St Mark, such inclusion would not exclude his identification. See for instance ter Brugghen's St Mark in the Historisch Museum Deventer

As for the attribution, I still think Florentine ca 1650 is a good fit. If by Dolci, it isn't one of his highly polished paintings that align with Sassoferrata's - ex the St Jerome cited above. Here we're seeing a style that is closer to that of Vignali who was his teacher

Jacinto Regalado,

Here is a Dolci St Mark, apparently an early work (c. 1640), when a teacher's influence would presumably have been stronger than later in his career. However, the typical high finish is already evident:

https://bit.ly/346IUrN

Jacinto Regalado,

The iconography is much more in keeping with a St Jerome than a St Mark, not only the skull but also the degree of nakedness, though no doubt an exception is possible (although two exceptions together seem rather less likely).

Would the presence of an angel with a trumpet in the upper right not suggest Jerome rather than Mark?

Attached is a detail of the text in case it means anything to anyone.

1 attachment
Nicholas De Gaetano,

Yes you're right about the trumpet, and I was thinking about that earlier. But St Mark is sometimes depicted alongside an angel (see the attached for two examples, even though these don't feature long trumpets). The main reason why I initially doubted whether it could be St Jerome is the colour of the his mantle. St Jerome's is invariably red, whilst St Mark's is either dark blue/green.

2 attachments
Nicholas De Gaetano,

Do you have other details of this painting, aside from the one showing the inscription? I would appreciate seeing a good close up of the face and right hand

Jacinto Regalado,

Dolci appears to show hermit saints as relatively emaciated, which is not the case here, and the whole feel of the picture strikes me as too muscular/sinewy/masculine for Dolci.

Mark Wilson,

The fact that this shows St Jerome with an open book displaying writing might suggest that it is meant to emphasise his position as one of the four Latin Church Fathers (along with St Gregory the Great, St Augustine and St Ambrose).

There's a painting of St Gregory (also with an open book) at the Walters Art Museum:

https://art.thewalters.org/detail/9071/saint-gregory-the-great/

which is also octagonal and similar size (128 x 106 cm, this is 112 x 89) which came from the ceiling of the library in the Dominican convent of Santa Maria Novella in Florence. It's by Jacopo Vignali and dated to around 1630. Could this be related to that?

There's also an octagonal St Ambrose, almost the same size as the Walters St Gregory, still in Florence, attributed to Vignali at the Museum of the Ospedale degli Innocenti (pdf download):

https://sigecweb.beniculturali.it/sigec/item/print/ICCD5173858

Nicholas De Gaetano,

Yes I'm not 100% sure it's by Dolci (and I too have not studied Florentine 17th century art in great detail) but I'm sure it's Florentine 17th century.

For what it's worth here are some other paintings by Dolci that suggested his name to me.

It would be a good idea to contact Dott Francesca Baldassarre for her views. She's the current leading authority on this artist.

2 attachments

Nicholas, in reply to your message 22/05/2021 15:28, please find attached details from the hand, face and inscription from the image file in the Art UK record, which clearly is somehow not the one shown on the Art UK site. I will ask relevant people at Art UK today if that can be corrected to help this discussion. Moreover, I noted an equally different colouring on the COLLAGE website with a zoom facility for other details (https://bit.ly/3bOzdm8). I have asked the Collection if they might have a better quality image. David

3 attachments
Nicholas De Gaetano,

Thanks for sending these details which are very helpful. On the basis of these I do not think the painting is Florentine 17th century or close to Dolci. Sorry about this, but let's continue discussing because it's a good picture that will certainly lead to an identification

Andrew Shore,

The inscription text kind of looks Italian, and says something like:

bona ineroma a l'ore orazione tre mentre che il tempo va gli da via ha opportuna di [placate?] [quest?] peccatore

...which would mean something like:

good nature in the third hour of prayer, while that time goes away, he has the opportunity to appease this sinner

I realise that doesn't necessarily make very much sense(!) but perhaps someone recognises it as something written by Jerome?

Mark Wilson,

According to the website of the Biblioteca Domenicana at Santa Maria Novella:

https://www.bibliotecadomenicana.eu/storia/

there was an extension built to the library between 1618 and 1636, which ties in nicely with the 1630s date that the Walters give to their St Gregory. The extension was then demolished to build Florence's first railway station in 1847, so any structural paintings (as this must be with the shape) would no longer be required and difficult to place elsewhere and so likely to go on the market.

The London picture was bequeathed to the City by William Dunnett in 1888, so that would tie in with the pictures being dispersed after the demolition. And according to the Guildhall website (https://bit.ly/3ff9vcA) "Dunnett is believed to have spent much of his life at Vicopelago [now part of Lucca] in Italy building up a miscellaneous collection of paintings, antiquities and other items". So clearly he was in the right place to buy Florentine paintings.

The St Jerome is a bit smaller than the St Gregory and St Ambrose (which are 128 x 106 and 130 x 110, so close as to suggest linkage) but not all four Church Fathers would necessarily be the same size in a decorative scheme, it would depend on the architecture of the extension. Artists would adjust to cope as in this asymmetrical piece by Vigneli:

https://artmuseum.princeton.edu/collections/objects/32932

Certainly Vigneli seems a more likely artist for the St Jerome than Dolci whose work seems sweeter and softer, perhaps reflecting later tastes. Obviously there will be some similarities as Dolci was Vignali's pupil, but this looks more like the latter.

Jacinto Regalado,

It would seem we need a Vignali expert, if there's one to be had.

Jacinto Regalado,

The new and improved photo of the picture in question shows greater finish, but I still doubt it is by Dolci.

Nicholas De Gaetano,

Kindly note I wrote to Prof Francesca Baldassari about this painting. As mentioned above she is the leading authority on Dolci and artists from his circle. Whilst she agreed with me that the painting is Florentine dating to the 1650s, she said that the painting is "very close to the young Florentine painter Alessandro Rosi". To be sure, she must see it in person.

Jacinto Regalado,

For some reason, the image shown with this discussion looks different on different computers. On the one I am using right now, it looks abnormally yellowish and slightly blurry, which is not how it looks when one opens the separate entry for the picture on Art UK (which is how it looks on a different computer to me). This may be a problem for interested parties, such as in Italy, who could contribute to the discussion given an optimal image.

Please support your comments with evidence or arguments.

jpg, png, pdf, doc, xls (max 6MB)
Drop your files here
Attach a file Start uploading
 

Sign in

By signing in you agree to the Terms & Conditions, which includes our use of cookies.