Photo credit: Bolton Library & Museum Services, Bolton Council
Another portrait of the sitter was painted by George Patten (1801–1865). The following is an excerpt from the Manchester Courier, Saturday 3rd October 1840, p.5:
‘BOLTON. Dinner to George Patten, Esq. On Wednesday George Patten, Esq., A. R. A., met the committee and a party of the subscribers to the Vicar of Bolton's portrait at dinner, at the Swan Hotel. The magnificent painting of the Rev. J. Slade occupied a prominent place the room, and, along with proof of the exquisite engraving from it by Thomas Lupton, Esq., elicited the warmest approbation of the subscribers and their friends.’
A DNB entry for James Slade says the painting had hung in the Church of England Educational Institution at Bolton. A description of the Slade painting by Patten features in the Monthly Magazine v.1, 1839, p.625 ‘painted in his surplice at the altar of the parish church of Bolton le Moor’, so it would seem that this is not the Patten version but a later version. The attached image seems to match the description of Patten's earlier portrait.
A later portrait is referred to in the Cheshire Observer Saturday 9th February 1856, p.8: ‘the parishioners have shown their high appreciation of his [Rev Canon Slade's] eminent services [...] by presenting him with his full-length Portrait; and it is rather singular that within the last few days, we have met with the copy of a printed letter which he addressed to the secretary of the committee appointed upon that occasion, to superintend the execution of the work, and which vividly pourtrays his own character’.
This discussion is now closed. The artist has been identified as Joshua Horner (1811–1881) and the painting has been dated to 1855.
Thank you to everyone who contributed to the discussion. To anyone viewing this discussion for the first time, please see below for all the comments that led to this conclusion.
Lupton's mezzotint after Patten's full length portrait can be found on the British Museum database 1931,1211.72. The portrait under discussion here is quite evidently by a different artist.
The direct link to the Lupton/Patten print at the BM is here: http://bit.ly/2zQ5hAU
I wonder if what we have is the 1854 oil portrait of Slade "by Mr T. Whalley of Preston" which was "procured" (?commissioned) by J Menzies of Bolton, and exhibited at his Picture Gallery from December that year. He published a low-cost steel engraving after it by "John Lacont of Edinburgh" at the same time, enabling him to sell the prints much more cheaply (between 5 shillings &10s; 6d) than the Lupton/Collen mezzotint - in Dec 1856 (after Slade's retirement) the latter was being offered by John C Grundy of Manchester at prices between one and four guineas, in competition with both Menzies and another dealer (presumably also offering the Le Conte/Walley one). See attachments 1 & 2. The errors in Menzies' first advertisement had been corrected in further ones in January 1855 - the original artist is now given as "Mr Walley" [Thomas Walley, 1817-1878], and the engraver is "J. Le Conte" [John Le Conte, 1816-1877]. Attachment 3. The (original) portrait was exhibited in Bolton until mid-Feb 1855, and then moved on to Chester in early March (attachments 4 & 5). Menzies was still offering "a few copies still remaining" of the print in June 1860, shortly after Slade's death - the price had been reduced to between 3s and 5s (attachment 6).
But could this in fact be the testimonial portrait apparently presented to Slade by parishioners in Feb 1856? They could have easily have bought it off Menzies later in 1855. But the Le Conte print measured 15 in x 12 in - proportions of 1.25:1 seems unlikely to be right for a full-length (the Lupton/Collen is 1.6:1)...and if it was, then the "most truthful likeness" of his face must have been pretty small. Here's another print by Le Conte of about the same size: http://bit.ly/2irp1DL . It's true that his print of Slade is described as an oval, but I don't think this is a serious objection - oval prints based on rectangular portraits are not uncommon. But I am still unsure, and as well as looking at other portrait work by Walley, we really need to find a copy of the print.
On reading the full letter to the Cheshire Observer published on 9th February 1856 and part-quoted above, I believe Mr Lampert may have misinterpreted what is written there - see attachment.
My reading of it is that the writer is almost certainly referring to the 1839 Patten full-length portrait presented to the sitter in 1840, not to a new portrait, also full-length - hence the correspondent finding it "rather singular" (i.e. quite a coincidence) that while writing in 1856 about the desirability of testimonials to men like Slade, he had just come across a printed letter written by the same man "upon that occasion" when his portrait was being discussed (over 15 years earlier) that rather dismissed the value of earthly testimonials.
If I'm right, this gives support to the theory that our portrait is the one by Walley.
Bolton Museum and Art Gallery's 1856 portrait of Dr George Wolstenholme J P by Thomas Walley gives some to Osmund's suggestions. Was the engraving also used as a frontispiece to a book written by Slade? An oval might have been thought better for a publication.
Slade founded the Church Institute School in 1855 . Since 1944 it has been the Canon Slade Grammar School in Bradshaw see Gayle McBain , ' A School with a long history' , The Bolton News 4 December 2014
A reduced (?cut down) version of the Lupton/Patten print is in the NPG: http://bit.ly/2kpLxBi
There are two Walley paintings held by Bolton Museum & Art Gallery, one a comparable male portrait: http://bit.ly/2jkdrey
Actually, according to Wright & Gordon's 2006 'British & Irish Paintings in Public Collections' Bolton should have a third, an 1865 portrait of Richard Harwood, Mayor Of Bolton in 1863/64. Its inventory number in 1999 was 1888.12 (and in a 1903 catalogue it was number 62) - why isn't that on Art UK, I wonder?
Four other portraits - two of children, and two of women (very possibly family) - went through Bonhams Oxford in 2015: http://bit.ly/2km4FA6 & http://bit.ly/2jlSYq2
There is an extensive biography of Canon Slade here...but sadly no portrait: http://bit.ly/2zQVdro . There is also a fuller memoir of him written in 1892 by his successor as Vicar of Bolton, J A Atkinson, that would be worth checking for an illustration, but I can't find it online. There must surely be copies of the Le Conte/Walley print in public collections - perhaps it has no inscription, and they languish unidentified? A long job for someone there, perhaps, going through the BM collection looking for anonymous oval portraits of C19th clergymen...
In the school joined up with St James C of E High School in Farnworth to become an academy Bolton News 3 May 2016. It is possible that the Patten portrait is now in one of the Academy's buildings. It is now the Bishop Fraser Trust. Its librarian might be able to provide more information
Excellent thought, Martin...and I've been busy on the phone. The Canon Slade school still exists (and will remain) as a separate entity, but is now an academy and "part of a (very small) multi-academy trust" (Bishop Fraser). The school librarian put me on to the Clerk to the Trustees, Simon Rees, and he has been exceptionally friendly and helpful (I've just spoken to him) - yes, they've got the full-length Patten portrait...and also another smaller one. I've got to dash out now, but will write further when I get back.
[Sorry, some of my info overlapped with Martin's when we were posting at the same time - and note that in my first long post above I wrote about the 'Lupton/Collen' print a couple of times by mistake instead of 'Lupton/Patten'.]
I think that a picture of the Richard Harwood portrait by Walley can be found unidentified on pinterest
I can't find that, Martin - have you a link?
Mr Rees is going to take some snaps of their two (oil) portraits of Canon Slade (one, I think, being the Patten full-length), and see if he can find any info about the other on the picture itself or elsewhere. He's also sending me a biographical pamphlet they have about Slade which includes a portrait of some sort. He thinks there may also be a picture (?print) in the parish church.
However...further discoveries in the BNA lead me to suspect that our portrait of Slade is not the Walley portrait after all! Further articles [attached] in the (weekly) Bolton Chronicle from Dec 1855 talk about yet another, then very recent oil portrait of the Canon by Joshua Horner [1812-1884] of Halifax – this was also exhibited by Menzies in Bolton. It was said to be “life-sized”, but presumably not full-length (such a huge size would surely have been mentioned?). Measuring the proportions of our portrait’s image, I calculate that the sitter’s head is about 23.5 cm high – and that is indeed pretty much life-size.
Most significantly, though, in the last of those pieces (15 Dec) the Walley portrait is also mentioned, and described as representing the vicar "as he appears in the pulpit" – in our portrait the sitter is unquestionably in “mufti”, *not* in the full clerical robes he’d have worn when taking a service. So I think Horner is now the front-runner for our portrait’s artist.
There, however, we have a slight problem. Though there is a certain amount online about Joshua Horner, I can find no images of his work other than the small group on Art UK attributed to him that is held by Calderdale B. Council ( http://bit.ly/2jlmigm ). It is clear, though, that these cannot all be by the same man – the quality is wildly divergent, and the two self-portraits of 1839 & 1850 must surely be different people. Horner was from an artistic family, and his sons (John and another Joshua) are said to have also painted portraits – possibly, too, his father (?)John. I would guess that these have all been mixed up, and heaven knows which one painted Slade (I will try and get to the bottom of the genealogy in due course). Joshua has slightly emerged from obscurity of late as the supposed artist of a c1830 portrait of Anne Lister, Britain’s “first modern lesbian”, as the BBC & Guardian have excitedly described her.
The pinterest reference eludes me when I search
Could we ask the Collection if they have any further information on who gave them this portrait in (?)1913, and also (as ever) if there is anything - labels, inscriptions, etc - on the back and/or the frame?
I wonder, too, if they have an image of the missing 1865 portrait of Mayor Richard Harwood by Thomas Walley, accession no (apparently) BOLMG:1888.12.
As so much information has come forward, this discussion is worth reanimating. Did the collection ever reply with snaps Osmund mentioned?
And could the collection check its records and the back of the picture to see if there is anything, however seemingly insignificant, which might help.
Canon Slade certainly seems to be older in the Bolton portrait than he does in the one by George Patten of 1840, so we are looking at a work that most likely dates from the 1850s, and which might well be the one by Joshua Horner of 1855 referred to by Osmund.
The Royal Academy exhibition catalogue for 1839 shows, on page 18, that George Patten's portrait was exhibited in the Middle Room as item number 317, and was described as 'Portrait of the Rev. James Slade, Vicar of Bolton-le-Moors and Prebendary of Chester. Painted at the request of the inhabitants of Bolton'.
It still seems worthwhile keeping this discussion going. If Bolton could oblige with some photographs of the back of the painting or an account of what is there, it might help.
Osmund has told us something about Joshua Horner (son of the landscape painter John), but we need to know more. He would seem to be the same young artist whose letters from his travels on the continent were published in 1841 (having originally appeared in the Halifax Express). His tour in Europe suggests an artist who gained competency at a young age. But he did not exhibit at the Royal Academy, nor at the British Institution, although he clearly had a reputation in Halifax and was known to have painted copies of Old Masters while abroad. He painted a portrait of a Halifax banker in 1866. The London Gazette reported that Joshua Horner had died in 1881. Can he be considered a viable candidate as the painter of the portrait of Canon Slade?
Good morning, Barbara. I have emailed the Collections Access Officer at Bolton and hope to have a reply soon.
Matthew Watson, Collections Access Officer at Bolton Library and Museums Service, has emailed:
'The painting is hanging on the wall so it is not possible to take a photo of the back. I doubt very much it would reveal anything interesting anyway. If there was any information on the back it would have been noted on our database.
We have very little information about the portrait beyond the fact it was donated to the museum by a Mr J. Harrison, an accountant, who lived in Great Lever, Bolton. He donated it in 1913.
We don’t have an image of the missing Richard Harwood but we do have the attached (BOLMG:1999.122). https://bit.ly/2QecMNG
Dr Wolstenholme, who was the first house surgeon at the Bolton Dispensary, Nelson Square. First Certifying Surgeon under the Cotton Mills Act.
Thomas Walley was a portrait painter from Blackburn who was commissioned to do portraits of several mill-owners, so it is not inconceivable that he may also have been commissioned to paint Canon Slade around the same time.
'The painting is hanging on the wall so it is not possible to take a photo of the back. I doubt very much it would reveal anything interesting anyway. If there was any information on the back it would have been noted on our database.'
Wow! What a worryingly dismissive set of statements. Firstly, if the painting is hanging on a wall, what impediment is there to simply talking it off the wall, photographing the back, rehanging it and making that image available to this discussion? Secondly, numerous examples of Art Detective observations contradict the notion that an examination of the back of a painting would not reveal anything interesting. And thirdly, now is it that Bolton Library etc cannot definitively confirm that all the relevant information to be found on the back of the painting has not already been meticulously and professionally recorded on their database? Attention to these three points might help significantly reduce the time taken by voluntary contributors to the Art Detective service to speculate about sitter identifications and artist attributions.
These are the PCF images of Canon Slade and Dr Wolstenholme.
I have received an email from Matthew Watson, Bolton Library and Museum Services. Matthew explained that the Portrait of Canon Slade currently features in a display in the museum called Faces of Bolton. It is displayed high up on one of the grand staircases leading up to the museum floor. The painting could be not taken down without the construction of scaffolding, which would be costly and very time-consuming. He would like to reassure readers of this thread that the museum maintains meticulous records of paintings in the collection including any inscriptions on the back of paintings, so he is confident that the back of the painting does not include any reference to the artist who made it.
It is a shame no further progress has been made on this discussion. We know we cannot get further information from the collection so we have to rely on the excellent evidence found by Osmund in local newspapers (see above).
Other than the portrait by George Patten exhibited at the RA in 1839 (which is recorded and located so not an issue), the two artists who we know painted portraits of Canon Slade are Thomas Whalley (1817-1878) of Preston and Joshua Horner (1812-1884) of Halifax. Unfortunately very little is known about these two artists who operated in the northwest of England. The portraits were done in the 1850s so Slade would have been aged in his 70s (he died age 77 in 1860).
What we have not seen are two biographies of Slade, which (optimistically) might show these portraits. Libraries being difficult to access these days, it may be we can't look at these sources but we will give it another couple of weeks.
A Google search brought up this reference to a photograph of Slade on the website of the Bolton Librariy and Museum Services: Slade, Canon James 1. Portrait of Canon James Slade. ID, 2059loc. Date found, 1820 (circa). Object type, photograph. Reference number, LS2059.
Unfortunately, the link to the actual webpage is broken, but I lifted a copy of the photograph from Google images. Sorry, I know it is very small, but it is so similar to the painting that I wonder if the painting was not done after the photograph? If that is the case, it could have been painted at any time.
The Canon Slade School portraits are perhaps seen here? sadly the quality is poor; the full length colour portrait is captioned 'Canon Slade invigilates'
If our picture were after the photo found by Maria Castro, it would not be an inverted image--unless it is after an engraving made from the photo and also inverted.
I've sent an e-mail to the library to see if we can find out more about the photo. I am also a bit baffled by the date that seems to be in the catalogue listing, since it can obviously not be the date of the photograph.
PS: after some more reading, and despite the wording in the catalogue listing, I don't think the image that I referred to above can be a photograph, given that only daguerrotypes or possibly ambrotypes or tintypes would have been available during Slade's lifetime. It don't think that's what we are looking at, and it would probably have been noted in the catalogue accordingly. I am wondering in fact whether it is not one of the prints from the steel engraving that was made at the same time as Whalley's portrait according to info earlier in the discussion. That would lead us back to the possiblity that the portrait is the one by Whalley after all. I'll update info once I hear back from the museum services.
Just to clarify some points above, here are enlarged details of the portraits at the Canon Slade School in Bolton which J. Foster has helpfully cited.
The full length by Patten we know about and don't need to pursue further.
The other one is interesting as this could be either the one by Walley (not Whalley as I had before) or the one by Horner.
Here is the image of Slade (in a larger size) found by Maria Castro in the collections of the Bolton Library and Museum Service. I wonder if it is possible that this is the "fine steel engraving" (or a version thereof) by John Le Conte after Walley's portrait, cited in the newspaper article of December 1854.
If so, Walley's portrait is the one at the School. And that would rule him out as the painter of the portrait under discussion which might then, logically, be the one by Horner.
This catalogue, held at Bolton Library History Centre would perhaps help, (maybe the Museum staff have access to a copy?):
'Bolton Art Patrons:an exhibition of oil paintings and sculpture lent or given to the town by families connected with Bolton,1st to 27th September 1967'
Bolton Museum and Art Gallery:
The enlargement from Barbara of the image found by Maria is consistent with an engraving, especially evident in the hair, which would not look like that in any sort of photograph.
I've received an e-mail from Julie Lamara who is the Collections Access Officer for Local Studies for the Bolton History Centre. She sent me a copy of the original image as well as one of Mrs Slade. She isn't able to access the physical catalogue card at the moment, but hopes to be able to get into the building next week. She says there is no information on the back of the mount.
The image of Mrs. Slade is clearly a photo.
Yes, Mrs Mary Slade (nee Bolling) appears in a Victorian carte de visite style studio photograph such as Camille Silvy produced. It probably dates from the early 1860s, which would be consistent with her age (b.1793). This image is not the same as the image of Canon Slade which seems to show an engraving or photo of an engraving. If there were any comments on the back of the mount of the Canon Slade that would be good to know.
Unfortunately, Julie Lamara said there is no information on the back of the mount at all, though she will try to check the physical catalogue next week to see if there is any further information.
I think what we really need now is a much better photograph of the second portrait of Slade (the one at the school) so that we can compare the engraving to the two portraits. Is that possible?
I have a lot of further information and better images to share, much of it thanks to the efforts of Simon Rees, Clerk to the Trustees of the Canon Slade School in December 2017. However at the time a complicated Xmas & New Year, followed by a long succession of demanding family issues here and in France, gradually pushed this discussion (and other equally tricky ones) further and further into the background, and in due course I all but forgot about it (or at least tried to!). However, Barbara's resurrection of matters - and an impressively energetic response from Maria Castro and J Foster - have finally spurred me into action, but the long gap means I have to reacquaint myself with everything I knew and understood 2½ years ago. My brain is also not working too well just now, I don't know why, so bear with me. I will take it in stages, and also seek some clarifications from Simon Rees if he is still in post.
First instalment will follow later today.
Excellent news, Osmund. I felt sure you would have some input on this one. Do take your time. I know it took me time to get my head around all the ins and outs again.
Hello Osmund. Any further thoughts on Slade?
I had the following e-mail response from Julie Lamara at the Bolton History Centre:
I have managed to gain access to the index of photographs and images we hold in Bolton History Centre.
Unfortunately the index card does not give any further information about the portrait of Canon Slade not where it came from.
Even the date of 1820 has a question mark against it.
I am sorry I could not help you further.
So, unfortunately, no further information there. The 1820 date was dubious anyway.
Further to my entry on 21 July, I have now seen Atkinson's memoir of Canon Slade (1892) and it does NOT contain any portrait images of him, nor any references to portraits painted, so that is a dead end.
Here is another, oval, portrait of Canon Slade, from an online publication 'Bright Star in the Present Prospect: The University of Chester 1839 - 2015 (by Ian Dunn) 2005. Cheshire archives online image bank does not seem to have this
Perhaps held at Chester Cathedral archives.
Right, finally. Canon Slade School currently owns *three* different oil portraits of Canon Slade, along with a print or photo of the largest of them, plus a print or photo of yet another rather better portrait that hadn't featured on the thread until J Foster posted an image of it earlier. This last (seated) one, either an original oil or a print after it, may be at Chester Cathedral – the school was given a photograph of it in around 1974, and this featured in the school magazine ‘The Sladian’ the same year. See attachment 1. I don’t think, though, it is relevant to our discussion, as it has no visual connection with our portrait, and I don’t think it is either of the ones we are trying to pin down – i.e. Thomas Walley’s of 1854, and Joshua Horner’s of 1855.
The first oil owned by the school is the full-length portrait of 1839 by George Patten (exhib RA same year), and engraved by Thomas Lupton in 1840. They also have either a copy of the print, or a photo of the painting (or the print) – it’s not clear which, but it doesn’t matter. As Barbara has said, we need not concern ourselves further with this work, as we know all about it, and it doesn’t relate in any way to our portrait. Just for the record, attachment 2 is an illustration of the original painting that's in a school history booklet that Mr Rees sent me. It is also the painting spotted by J Foster in the background of a colour photo on the school’s website, ‘Canon Slade invigilates’.
The next one they have is clearly a smaller version of ours, approx 14 x 10 in. (35½ x 25½ cm), but in an oval format. This was given to the school c.2012; it was in very poor condition, and subsequently restored by a very reputable conservator. It seems inferior in execution to our one (unless the restoration was very poor!), and I would guess it is a copy after ours. Attachment 3 shows it alongside ours (with another image showing its true relative size).
The third oil is the one also spotted by JF in a B&W photo of the Library from 1956, and shows Canon Slade preaching. The two images of it are in Attachment 4. The one I have from Mr Rees at the school unfortunately cuts off the top, but from the ‘Library’ photo we can see that the frame, which looks original, has an arched top. This is relevant, as a comparable portrait of George Wolstenholme by Thomas Walley at Bolton Museum & Art Gallery (https://bit.ly/3l4vGDb) has a similarly arched top. I don’t know the size of the school’s portrait, but from the full ‘Library’ photo it looks like it could be the same size (attachment 5) – if the discussion stays open long enough I will ask Mr Rees if he can measure it for us.
Note that a contemporary (1855) press report of the Walley portrait states that “the vicar is represented as he appears in the pulpit” – attachment 6 (a repost). I believe that makes it all but certain that this is Thomas Walley’s portrait of 1854.
I must go to bed now, but tomorrow I will return to our portrait, and show why I think it’s highly likely that it’s the one painted by Joshua Horner in 1855.
All most interesting, Osmund. Thank you. Previously I leaned to Horner for our portrait (and more or less composed what follows). You now make that seem even more likely. Horner, he of Anne Lister's now famous portrait (assuming he is the Horner who painted it) and that of her brother, appears the more competent artist. And we do have that tiny piece of evidence which says that Walley's portrait shows Canon Slade as he was "in the pulpit", whereas in the portrait under discussion shows him in more ordinary dress (see Osmund's account of this at 7.12.17). Osmund's new posted photo of the other portrait of Slade shows the pulpit quite clearly. So, by process of elimination, Horner is the painter of our portrait. Osmund, if there is more, it would be great to know.
The 'process of elimination' is certainly part of it - but that could in theory also apply to the newly-revealed portrait/print apparently at Chester Cathedral (or in their archives). As an oval, it was briefly tempting to think that the latter might be a copy of, or the source for the 15 x 12 in. oval engraving we know was made of the Walley portrait - however, we can eliminate it as it doesn't show Canon Slade 'in the pulpit'. But it cannot be ruled out altogether as a candidate for the Horner. Fortunately, though, there *is* more to support the idea that ours is the Horner, and the key is, I believe, the carte-de-visite photograph of Slade found by Maria Castro.
Slade's lifetime just missed the craze for CDVs and photos taken for them, so his image had to be found (as was not uncommon) in an existing portrait. The larger images provided by Barbara and the Collection suggest it might be a photograph of an engraving, but there is another possibility. Maria noted how like it is to our painting (see attached comparison), and I think I know why.
In its report of Slade sitting for Joshua Horner, the Bolton Chronicle of 8 Dec 1855 (after a piece in the Halifax Guardian) described, "... two portraits, the size of life, one in crayon and the other in oil. The former is ably elaborated in Mr. Horner’s admirable style of crayon portraits, having almost all the finish of a rich line engraving. In the latter Mr. Horner has obtained a more pleasing expression; but both are excellent likenesses, and are well worthy to be engraved." [Re-attached]
There's no evidence either of them ever was engraved - presumably it was felt the market was already saturated, with two different prints (Le Conte/Walley and the earlier Lupton/Patten) available and much-advertised. But I think it highly likely that Bolton's CDV is a vignetted photograph of Horner's crayon portrait of Canon Slade, and ours is his oil.
There is much more to write (I've been busy) on Joshua Horner of Halifax and his father John, both artists, but it can wait for a new dedicated discussion - perhaps one around his attributed portrait of 'Gentleman Jack' Anne Lister, which will certainly please the powers-that-be at Art UK. Just for starters, though, Joshua actually lived from 1811-1881, not 1812-1884 as given.
Osmund, I think you've nailed it! That's great! It is a pity that we don't have the original crayon portrait for comparison, but this would explain the slight differences in the hairline, for example, or the neckline of the garment, between the image at the Bolton History Centre and the oil under discussion.
Osmund, it is wonderful that you have pieced together the vignetted photo with Horner's missing crayon drawing of Slade. Thanks to Maria Castro and J. Foster for contributing key information. I am glad there is more to say about Horner (the younger) as he seems an interesting artist, with his travel in Europe studying and copying before and after 1840 (see my comment at 8/11/2018). He then had a career as a professional portraitist in Halifax. I now recommend closing this discussion with the new identification of Joshua Horner (with his corrected life and death dates 1811-1881) as the painter of Canon Slade's portrait which can be dated to 1855.
I'll let the Bolton History Centre know so that they can perhaps update their catalogue.